© Wendy Anne Clark, 2026
A while back Jennifer Aniston appeared on the podcast Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard and made an old well-worn argument about faith, claiming that we only believe what we believe because of how and where we were raised. The argument is basically this: if you were raised by a Mormon family, you will be a Mormon; if you were raised Muslim, you will be a Muslim; if you were raised in a Christian family, you will be a Christian.
At first glance, this seems true, or at least mostly true. Most people do follow the religious teaching that they were raised in, atheists included.
At second glance, however, we see that how you were raised is no guarantee of what you will believe as you move into adulthood. Throughout all of history, we find examples of people who walked away from the religious tradition they were raised in, for many different reasons. Most of us can think of more than a few families where one or more children heads down a different, unexpected religious path.
Jennifer Aniston then claims that people of faith lack the critical-thinking skills required to examine their own beliefs, but how does she come to this conclusion? There have been enough intelligent educated Christians, deep thinkers of faith to challenge the idea that one can’t be both a critical thinker and a Christian. There have been enough scientists who are Christians to demonstrate that you can be a scientific thinker and also a believer. There have been rich and poor Christians, educated and uneducated, in all fields of study–too many to easily dismiss Christians as poor or uneducated or lacking the ability to think.
What evidence do we have that Jennifer Aniston is herself a critical thinker and has carefully examined and evaluated her lack of belief?
The problem with Jennifer Aniston’s argument is that it is rooted in the physical, material, world. According to her theory, where a person was physically born and raised and what that person was taught in the physical world is the biggest determining factor of how that person will believe. But this argument neglects to consider the spiritual aspect of who we are and how we are brought to faith in the spiritual.
What if we consider this question from a Biblical perspective? What does God reveal to us through His word about how we come to believe and the question of being born into an unbelieving culture?
Here’s what I see as I study the Bible:
God determined when and where each person would be born and live so that each person would have their best opportunity to seek after God, find Him, and be saved. That’s how I interpret what Paul says in Acts 17:26-27:
“And He made from one man every nation of mankind to live on all the face of the earth, having determined allotted periods and the boundaries of their dwelling place, that they should seek God, and perhaps feel their way toward Him and find Him. Yet He is actually not far from each one of us . . .”
As I understand what Paul is saying, Jennifer Aniston was born in the best time and place for her to come to the point where she would seek after God, find Him, and be saved. Being born into a different family, in a different time and place would not have presented a better opportunity for her to be saved.
How can this be? Because God knows what He is doing, and it is by His Spirit that we are saved, and the Holy Spirit is not hindered by time and space and the circumstances of our upbringing. In fact, He can use unusual circumstances to His own advantage. Coming to faith in Jesus is a spiritual activity, not a physical one. Jesus says this, “No one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws them” (John 6:44).
Many people do continue to believe exactly what their parents believed and taught them. Yes. Ungodliness is carried on, generation after generation. And godliness is carried on, generation after generation. And yet . . . at any time, any one person can step outside of the pattern, the long strand, woven throughout history, and head in a new direction, and carry all those who come after them in a new direction. This happens on both sides of faith.
My mother’s parents were Christians. They raised four children. Only my mom consistently followed Jesus and raised her children in the Christian faith. The other three children all made other choices, which are reflected in the turmoil their children experienced. Some of those children know and follow Jesus, and others do not.
My father’s parents were not Christians and lived very worldly lives, yet my dad responded to the Gospel and was saved when he was in college. He married my mom, and they raised their five children in the Christian faith. All of the children believe, but not all have followed exactly the same.
If you are a Christian, you can teach your children and live in such a way that you make it easier for them to believe. You can remove barriers that otherwise might hinder their faith, but they will still have to choose, and there is nothing you can do to guarantee the choice they will make. Jennifer Aniston talks about being born into a Greek Orthodox tradition, which she describes in terms that make it seem strange and scary. Interestingly, she did not adopt the religion of her ancestors. Why not? And doesn’t the fact that she chose differently undermine her claim?
Oprah Winfrey talks about growing up in the Baptist tradition but rejecting her family’s faith when encountering teaching about God that she did not understand and did not explore in any depth: that God is a “jealous God.” If the God of the Bible is “jealous,” she surmised, He can’t be perfect and holy, therefore, He is disproved in her eyes. On her show she once stated that there is no way that Jesus could be the only way to God because too many people have been born in times and places where they did not hear about Jesus. This too is an argument from the physical and material, rather than the spiritual.
The Bible, which is a collection of writings which God has used to tell us about Himself, about the world around us, and about us as humans, tells us that God can reveal Himself to anyone, anywhere, in any way that He wants to and that His first revelation to all people is through everything that He has made.
Romans 1:18-20
“For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who by their unrighteousness suppress the truth. For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them. For His invisible attributes, namely, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse.”
God can reveal salvation and Jesus at any time, to anyone.
How are Abraham and Moses and David saved? By believing that they are sinners and that God is the only source of their salvation. Can they reject Jesus and be saved? No. Jesus provided the way of their salvation even though they were looking forward to that day. In their time, the Law and the Prophets revealed the truth about God to them. When they believed and lived according to faith, God called this “righteousness.”
Hebrews 1:1-2
“Long ago, at many times and in many ways, God spoke to our fathers by the prophets, but in these last days He has spoken to us by His Son, whom he appointed the heir of all things, through whom also He created the world.”
Genesis 15:5-6, ESV
“And He brought him outside and said, ‘Look toward heaven, and number the stars, if you are able to number them.’ Then He said to him, ‘So shall your offspring be.’ And he believed the Lord, and He counted it to him as righteousness.”
Whole books have been written on this topic. Obviously, I’ve barely skimmed the surface here, but if you really want to understand how people before Christ are saved, the Bible does address this question, and many have argued that the same principles apply to those born in times and places where Christ was not preached to them.
My argument is that time and place doesn’t matter because God is bigger. Here are a few testimonies I have encountered along the way that support this idea. It is not difficult to find people who will testify to this truth. Listen to their stories and weigh how persuasive they are in supporting this point.
The first account I retell here comes from a missionary and what happened in a tribe. I’m telling it in my own words as I remember it told to me:
A tribal warrior set out into the jungle to spend time with the Great Spirit and receive his commissioning. As he was out in nature, he looked around and acknowledged all of the beauty and order and magnificence of nature, and he recognized that a Mighty Creator must be behind all that he could see. “If You are willing,” he asked, “show yourself to me.” Mist began to rise up from the jungle floor.
At that moment a Great Chief came out of the mist of the jungle and approached him. The tribal warrior was terrified, and fell to his knees. The Great Chief identified himself as “Jesus” and told the tribal warrior that he should get in his canoe, travel down the river to the village, and look for the missionary in the hut with a cross on the roof. “When you find the missionary,” the Great Chief told him, “Ask him to tell you about me. Then go back to your village and tell your people.” Then the Great Chief disappeared in the mist.
The tribal warrior followed the instructions that he had been given and got in his canoe and traveled to the village to look for the missionary. When he found the hut with the cross and the missionary inside, he told the missionary of his encounter with the Great Chief and of how the Great Chief told him to ask the missionary to tell him about this chief whose name was Jesus.
The missionary told the warrior of who Jesus is, how He was sent by His Father, God, the Creator of all things, to come to earth and live a perfect life as a human, and die as the perfect and final sacrifice for the sins of all of mankind. Of how this Jesus was executed and then three days later, rose up from the dead, walked the earth and taught for 40 more days before ascending into heaven to sit at the right hand of His Father, God, and of how He promised that He will return again, and that all who believe in Him and follow Him will be saved and spend eternity with Him.
The tribal warrior believed and repented of his sins, determined to become a follower of this Great Chief named Jesus.
This missionary asked him, “What did He look like?”
The tribal warrior described Him as a fierce and Mighty warrior with a magnificent headdress and full war paint, an awesome sight.
The tribal warrior went back to his village as he had been instructed and told all of the people there about this Great Chief named Jesus. Most of the people believed and repented and determined that they would follow Jesus.
How can someone who lives in a place where Jesus has never been preached about come to believe in Jesus? This is one way. God can bring the message to the person.
Here is a testimony I heard personally when I was visiting a church in Yreka, California:
A Japanese woman told of how when she was a little girl, living in Japan, she would lie out on the grass and look at the night sky, filled with stars and think about who would be so magnificent as to create all of these beautiful things. “If You are real, I would like to meet You,” she said into the night.
She lived a sad and broken life, and eventually lived in an orphanage where an American couple came and found her, adopted her, and took her home as their own child. They were a Christian couple and took her to church every Sunday, and through them, she turned to Jesus Christ as her Savior.
She was in her twenties when it occurred to her that God had answered that prayer that she had prayed while looking up at the stars as a little girl. “I would like to meet you,” she had prayed, and God had answered, “I can make that happen.”
How can someone who has never heard about Jesus come to believe in Him? This is one way. God can bring the person to the message.
Here’s a story I read about a young man coming to Jesus while living in a Muslim nation:
A young man was trying to be faithful and obedient in serving Allah. He had been told that there was no way to know Allah personally, but that didn’t feel right to him. No way at all?
He looked at everything around him, and to him it seemed that there was a Creator who was speaking to mankind, and he prayed that if that were true, the Creator would reveal Himself in a way that he could understand.
That night he had a dream. In the dream he was riding the bus, as he did every day. The bus approached a corner that he often saw but had never gotten off the bus to explore.
In his dream, he got off the bus, walked across the street, and saw a man with a green satchel over his shoulder. He approached the man, and the man reached into the bag and pulled out something and put it into his hands. He took whatever it was and put it into his pocket, walked back across the street, and got onto the next bus to continue his ride. This is where his dream ended, and he woke up.
The next day, he was on that bus, and as he approached the corner that he had seen in his dream, he saw the man with the satchel from his dream, standing on that corner, so he got off the bus, crossed the street, approached the man, and put out his hand as he had in the dream. The man reached into his bag and pulled out a Bible, and put it into his hand. He took the Bible and tucked it into his pocket as he had in the dream and went back across the street to take the next bus to his destination.
Later, when he returned home, he took out the Bible, and realizing that he had it in his possession only by a supernatural event, he began to read and study it. He, like many other Muslims before him, would read that Bible, cover to cover, seven times, before he decided that it was true and that he would completely surrender his life and become a follower of Jesus.
How can someone who has never encountered the Bible come to read it and to know Jesus as His Savior? This is one way. God Himself can orchestrate events to put the Bible in His hands.
Here’s another similar story:
A group of Christians determined that they would bring Bibles into Vietnam, but they were prevented from distributing them and ended up wrapping them in plastic and burying them at random places in the jungle. Years later, during the Vietnam War, Vietnamese soldiers would find these Bibles, perfectly intact, and read them, and many would turn to Jesus and be saved.
God is not bound by time and space. If you think that where or when a person is born is a hindrance to them coming to know Jesus and following Him, your idea of God is far too limited.
You may live in a physical location or in circumstances that make it more likely that you would believe in Jesus and be saved, but the Holy Spirit moves in the spiritual realm and interacts with hearts and minds, and He is not hindered by time or space.
And everyone, no matter where or when they have lived, has been able to perceive God through all that He has made. God calls to each one of us through creation. It is an open invitation to find Him.
I picture how this works like a game of tag. God created all things, and then He stands back and says, “Tag. You’re it.” And He points out to you all the things He has made and all that they reveal about who He is.
When you look and seek and take even the tiniest step of faith in His direction, and you say something like, “God, if You’re real, please show Yourself to me,” it’s like you’ve reached out your hand to touch him and said, “Tag, You’re it.”
And then God responds back to you, revealing more truth to you.
God is not hiding from you. He’s waiting for you to look and see and seek after Him. He’s waiting for you to want to know more.
Many people say something like, “Prove it to me, and I’ll believe.” But God says something like this: “Look around at what you already know. Believe and take a step of faith. And I will prove it to you.”
Jennifer Anniston’s conclusion about faith reveals that she has in mind a very small and limited version of God, not the God of the Bible. How big is God? Is He able to do far beyond all that we could ask or imagine? (The Apostle Paul, Ephesians 3:20)
How is it that many people throughout history have come to Jesus in the most hostile of conditions? Can we trust that God is big enough and good enough and creative enough to work out the details of drawing people to Himself?
If you aren’t so sure, start listening to people tell their stories of how the Holy Spirit found them, drew them to Jesus, brought them to believe, and changed them. Seek the truth, don’t just settle for what you have always believed.
It’s quite possible that Jennifer Aniston lives in a bubble, surrounded by people who make the same assumptions and that it hasn’t occurred to her to go looking outside of that bubble for the TRUTH.
If you have been convinced that all truth is relative, that there is no truth to search for, you will likely stay in your bubble and accept whatever you can easily perceive through your senses.
But if you want to know the TRUTH, that which is established outside of what we think, experience, and imagine, you are going to have to do some looking and some true critical thinking.
Lamentations 3:22-25
“The steadfast love of the Lord never ceases; His mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is Your faithfulness. ‘The Lord is my portion,’ says my soul, ‘therefore I will hope in Him.’ The Lord is good to those who wait for Him, to the soul who seeks Him.”
Isaiah 55:6-11
“Seek the Lord while He may be found; call upon Him while He is near; let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts; let him return to the Lord, that He may have compassion on him, and to our God, for He will abundantly pardon.
“‘For My thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways My ways,’ declares the Lord. ‘For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are My ways higher than your ways and My thoughts than your thoughts’.
“‘For as the rain and the snow come down from heaven and do not return there but water the earth, making it bring forth and sprout, giving seed to the sower and bread to the eater, so shall My word be that goes out from My mouth; it shall not return to Me empty, but it shall accomplish that which I purpose, and shall succeed in the thing for which I sent it.’”
Jennifer Aniston | Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard